Home /

Blog /

Tier 1, Tier 2 and Tier 3 Automotive Advertising Explained

Tier 1, Tier 2 and Tier 3 Automotive Advertising Explained

November 1, 2026
Tier 1, Tier 2 and Tier 3 Automotive Advertising Explained

Tier 1, Tier 2 and Tier 3 describe who pays for a car ad and what it is meant to do. Tier 1 is the manufacturer’s own advertising. Tier 2 is regional advertising run by dealer associations, usually built around offers. Tier 3 is the individual dealer’s local advertising, often partly reimbursed by the manufacturer through co-op. Research firm BIA uses the same three-way split.

In short:

  • BIA projects $10.7 billion in local automotive ad spend for 2026 across Tiers 1, 2 and 3, with 63.3% of it going to digital.
  • In that BIA forecast, new-car dealers (Tier 3) spend about $3.50 billion locally in 2026, dealer associations (Tier 2) $3.28 billion and manufacturers (Tier 1) $3.60 billion.
  • NADA puts total franchised dealer advertising at $9.96 billion in 2025, or $739 per new vehicle sold, rising to $791 per vehicle in the first half of 2026.
  • Co-op is not a fixed 50% or 100%: Kia says certified vendors can use 100% of its DAS funds, Stellantis lists 1:1 T3AC reimbursement on select products, and Subaru says percentages vary by retailer.
  • Tier 2 associations and Tier 3 dealers can bid on the same “[brand] dealer [city]” searches. As separate advertisers they compete in the same Google auction, so each can raise the other’s cost per click.

Below: the money at each tier, how co-op flows through certified vendor programs, and the bidding conflict between your association and your store. It is the view we bring as an automotive marketing agency that runs search and social for dealers, not a co-op administrator.

What do Tier 1, Tier 2 and Tier 3 mean?

Tier 1 is the automaker, Tier 2 the regional dealer association, Tier 3 the dealer. We found no manufacturer, NADA or Cox Automotive page that defines all three, so the clearest written definition comes from research firm BIA Advisory Services.

BIA’s February 2026 report defines Tier 1 as automotive manufacturers, Tier 2 as “Local Automobile Dealers Associations: Trade organizations representing local auto dealerships,” and Tier 3 as new and used car dealers. Manufacturers use the label too. Stellantis calls its dealer co-op fund the “Tier 3 Advertising Co-op (T3AC)”.

The common industry shorthand is that Tier 1 says “buy this,” Tier 2 says “buy now” and Tier 3 says “buy here.” One trap: vendor descriptions of OEM programs use “Tier 1 leads” for leads from the manufacturer’s own websites. That is a lead source, not an ad tier.

Here is how the three tiers differ in practice.

Tier Who it is Who pays Who controls targeting and creative Typical message Where the click usually goes
Tier 1 The manufacturer (OEM) The OEM’s marketing budget The OEM and its agencies Brand and model: “buy this” Brand site, model pages, dealer locator
Tier 2 Regional dealer advertising association Member dealers, through the association. Funding methods vary, and we found no public terms The association and its agency, not any single dealer Regional offers, events, sales: “buy now” A regional offer page or a list of member stores
Tier 3 The individual dealer or dealer group The dealer, with OEM co-op reimbursing eligible spend The dealer, within OEM co-op and pricing rules The store, its inventory, price and service: “buy here” The dealer’s own site and vehicle detail pages

What this means for you: as a Tier 3 dealer you help fund Tier 2, but you do not control it. Its ads can send a shopper to a page listing every store in the region, including the one across town. That matters most in search, where both of you are bidding on the same people.

How much is spent at each tier?

BIA forecasts roughly equal local spend at each tier in 2026, with dealers the most digital. These are BIA projections of local media spend, not measured totals, and they exclude manufacturers’ national budgets.

Tier (BIA) 2026 local ad spend, forecast Change vs 2025 Digital share
Tier 1: manufacturers, local only $3.60 billion +2.7% 60.5%
Tier 2: dealer associations $3.28 billion +1.9% 63.1%
Tier 3: new-car dealers $3.50 billion +2.4% 66.6%
Tier 3: used-car dealers $318.1 million +2.3% 59.9%
All three tiers $10.7 billion +2.4% 63.3%

What this means for you: dealer associations are forecast to spend almost as much locally as new-car dealers, so treat your association as a major buyer of the same local media and searches you buy, not a side program. BIA expects Tier 3 new-car dealer digital spend to grow at 3.6% a year through 2028 while traditional media declines 3.0% a year.

NADA measures something different: what franchised dealers report spending on their own books. NADA Data 2025 puts it at $9.96 billion for 2025, about $586,000 per dealership and $739 per new vehicle sold. The 2026 midyear report shows $5.04 billion for the first half of 2026 and $791 per new vehicle. NADA defines advertising as “advertising and sales promotion minus advertising rebates,” so its figure is net of rebates. Do not add NADA and BIA together; they count different things. Our post on how much car dealerships spend on advertising turns those numbers into a budget.

How does co-op advertising work for dealers?

The manufacturer sets aside money for dealer advertising, the dealer runs ads that meet the program rules, and part of the cost comes back. Today most brands route digital co-op through a certified vendor program, which often bills through the dealer’s parts statement and files the claim automatically.

The accrual formulas, meaning how much each store earns per vehicle or per dollar of invoice, sit behind dealer logins for current programs. We could not verify a current one for any brand. What manufacturers do publish is below.

Brand Program What the OEM’s public site says Reimbursement stated publicly
Kia Kia Digital, launched 2015 More than 40 certified vendors, all reviewed by Kia. Billing on the parts statement. DAS claims submitted automatically. Cancel with 30 days’ notice. Each digital advertising package includes “a recommended minimum key word list and bidding strategy” Certified vendors “eligible for 100% DAS utilization”
Stellantis (US) Stellantis Digital Program Certified website required before other services. Month to month, with a 10th of the month cancellation cutoff. Billing on the parts statement. Automatic T3AC submission. OEM leads cost $18 each Select products eligible for 1:1 T3AC and Bonus T3AC
Stellantis (Canada) Stellantis Digital Co-op covers “New Vehicle Digital Advertising” done through certified vendors. Voluntary, month to month Not stated
Subaru Certified Paid Search Program Aligned “with Subaru’s search strategy to reduce competition.” Shift Digital submits SAF claims. Month to month. Certified websites are excluded from that eligibility “SAF/co-op percentages vary by retailer”
Acura Acura Digital Dealer Program Vetted digital advertising providers and an enrollment portal Not published
INFINITI INFINITI Digital Program Certified providers at pre-negotiated prices Not published
GM, Ford and Lincoln GM Dealer Digital Solution Program, FordDirect Programs exist with enrollment or solution pages. No co-op rules on the public pages Not published
Honda, Toyota, Hyundai, Nissan, VW Dealer portal programs Behind dealer logins, or described only by vendors Not public

What this means for you: anyone who tells you “co-op pays 50%” for every brand is guessing. Your program guide in the OEM dealer portal is the only document that counts, and it changes. Shift Digital’s name appears on the Kia, INFINITI and Subaru program sites, so one administrator appears on all three programs even though the rules differ.

Stellantis changed the most this year. Trade press reports that its Marketing Covenant, effective October 1, 2026, routes DAP reimbursement for digital marketing only through certified providers, bars dealers from bidding on another Stellantis dealer’s DBA name, and adds a minimum advertised price for new Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep and Ram vehicles. We could not find a public Stellantis document confirming those details, so check your dealer portal before you rely on them.

Struggling with Google Ads campaigns? Book a meeting with Clickem

The Tier 2 and Tier 3 keyword overlap problem

Your association and your store want the same searches, so in Google Ads you bid against each other with money that partly comes from the same dealers.

Start with where the demand is. In Clickem’s October 2026 dataset of US Keyword Planner estimates, 34 “[brand] dealership” and “[brand] dealer near me” keywords across 17 brands drew 4,327,500 searches a month. That is 6.5 times the 665,300 for 18 generic new-car keywords. Those brand searches also cost more: a median of $5.22 for “[brand] dealership” against $4.02 for “car dealership,” and $5.31 for “[brand] dealer near me” against $3.11 for “car dealership near me.” The full dataset is in our automotive Google Ads benchmarks.

Now the auction mechanics, from Google’s own pages:

  • Google’s Unfair advantage policy forbids “trying to show more than one ad for your business, app, or site in a single ad location.” Since an April 14, 2025 clarification, one business may appear in different ad locations on the same page, but not twice in the same one.
  • The policy does not say how it treats a dealer association and its member dealers. An association and a dealer run separate accounts promoting separate sites, so on a shared query they compete as separate advertisers. Google’s Auction insights report shows you the other advertisers “participating in the same auctions,” including overlap rate and position above rate.
  • Google says you pay “what’s minimally required to clear the Ad Rank thresholds and beat the Ad Rank of the competitor immediately below you.”

Put together: when the association’s ad sits directly below yours on “[brand] dealer [your city],” its Ad Rank helps set the price of your click, and when yours sits below theirs, you set theirs. Both sides are funded at least partly by the same dealers, and every click the association wins on your city’s name lands on a page listing your competitors.

Manufacturers know this happens. Subaru describes its certified paid search program as aligned with its search strategy “to reduce competition,” and Kia ships every certified package with a recommended minimum keyword list and bidding strategy. Google will not referee it for you: its trademark policy says it “will not restrict” trademarks used as keywords.

Here is how we would split the terms. This is our recommendation, not a Google or OEM rule.

Query type Example Who should usually own it Why
Your dealership name “[Your store name] Toyota” You only Your cheapest, highest-intent clicks. Some OEM rules reportedly bar other same-brand dealers from it
Brand plus your city, or near me inside your market “toyota dealer [your city]” Tier 3 The shopper wants a store. Your vehicle detail pages convert; a regional dealer list adds a step
Brand plus region, or areas no single store serves “toyota deals [region]” Tier 2 Regional offers fit the query and no single dealer owns the geography
Model offers and incentives “[model] lease deals” Tier 1 and Tier 2, with Tier 3 on models you have in stock The offer is regional or national. You bid where your inventory gives the shopper a reason to choose you
Another brand’s dealers (conquest) “honda dealer near me” for a Toyota store Tier 3, if budget allows A store-level decision based on your inventory and margins
Service and parts “[brand] service near me” Tier 3 Fixed ops is store business; see fixed ops marketing

What this means for you: coordinate with the association’s campaigns, which you help pay for. Ask its agency for the keyword list, match types, location targets and negatives, check Auction insights for its domain, then propose it add your store name and city as negatives where you are the obvious choice.

One caution. Talk to the association about its own campaigns, not to rival dealers about theirs. Agreements between competing dealers about where each will or will not advertise can raise antitrust questions. The FTC’s 1995 order against the Santa Clara County Motor Car Dealers Association barred it from organizing an advertising boycott while saying it “does not prohibit the Association from engaging in joint advertising programs.” This is general information, not legal advice, so have counsel look at any written arrangement.

Can the manufacturer control your advertised price?

It can restrict the advertised price, not the price you sell at. Trade press reports that Stellantis’s new minimum advertised price policy “applies to the advertised price and does not set the final transaction price.”

Federal law judges these policies case by case. In Leegin (2007) the Supreme Court held that vertical price restraints are judged by the rule of reason. Earlier, in 2000, the FTC settled with the five major CD distributors over minimum advertised price rules tied to co-op funds, and said it would view with “great skepticism” co-op programs that effectively eliminate a retailer’s ability to discount. That case predates Leegin, so read it as history. State law can differ.

Whatever price your OEM allows, it still has to be a lawful advertised price. The FTC’s current staff view is that the most prominent price must include every dealer-required fee, and our guide to car dealer advertising rules covers that alongside finance and lease disclosures.

Co-op claim checklist

Use it before launch and each month when the statement arrives.

  1. Download the current program guide from your OEM dealer portal. Rules change, and Stellantis’s changed on October 1, 2026.
  2. Confirm your vendor is certified for your brand in the current program year. For Kia, Subaru and Stellantis, certification is what gets the claim filed or the spend reimbursed.
  3. Check eligibility product by product. Stellantis says “select” products qualify for 1:1 T3AC, Subaru excludes certified websites from that eligibility, and Stellantis Canada’s page describes co-op for new-vehicle digital advertising.
  4. Confirm what your OEM’s minimum advertised price or brand rules require before the ads go live, and get any required approvals in writing.
  5. Keep the evidence: invoices, screenshots, landing page URLs and run dates for every claimed campaign.
  6. Ask for invoices that separate media cost from management fees, so you can see exactly what was claimed.
  7. Reconcile the parts statement monthly. Kia and Stellantis bill program charges there, and vendor charges are easy to miss.
  8. Diary the exit terms: Kia asks for 30 days’ notice, Stellantis cancellations follow a 10th of the month cutoff.
  9. Do not bid on another same-brand dealer’s name if your program bars it.
  10. Check that every co-op ad meets federal and state price rules. Co-op eligibility does not make an ad compliant.
  11. Track reimbursement received against reimbursement claimed, by month.
  12. Judge co-op campaigns on cost per car sold, the same as everything else.

Do you have to use your OEM’s certified vendors?

No law requires it, but for several brands the reimbursement depends on it. So the real question is whether the certified option is cheaper after co-op, spend by spend.

Here is a worked example with round, hypothetical numbers. Say you put $20,000 a month into new-car search. If your program reimbursed half of eligible spend through a certified vendor, your net cost would be $10,000. A non-certified agency running the same $20,000 would cost you the full $20,000, so it would need to sell about twice as many cars to match the certified option on cost per car. That is a high bar on co-op-eligible spend.

It flips on spend that co-op does not cover. Where a program’s co-op is described as covering new-vehicle digital advertising, as on Stellantis Canada’s page, your used-car and service campaigns may earn nothing from certification. One workable split is a certified vendor on eligible new-car spend and a specialist on the rest. Check your OEM’s certified list before you hire anyone, including us, and use our 15 questions for choosing an automotive marketing agency to compare them. The search setup we recommend for dealers is in Google Ads for car dealerships.

Common questions

What is Tier 2 advertising in automotive?

Tier 2 is advertising run by regional dealer associations, the trade groups that represent local dealers of a brand. It usually promotes regional offers and events and is paid for by member dealers through the association. BIA forecasts $3.28 billion in Tier 2 local ad spend for 2026.

What is the difference between Tier 1 and Tier 3 advertising?

Tier 1 is the manufacturer selling the brand and the model. Tier 3 is the individual dealer selling its own store, inventory, prices and service. Tier 3 is often partly paid back by the manufacturer through co-op.

How much does dealer co-op reimburse?

It depends on the brand, the fund and the product. Kia says certified vendors are eligible for 100% DAS utilization, Stellantis lists 1:1 T3AC reimbursement on select products, and Subaru says percentages vary by retailer. Your OEM program guide is the only reliable source for your store.

Can a dealer association and a dealer bid on the same keywords?

Yes. Google’s policy stops one business from showing more than one ad in a single ad location, and nothing in it treats an association and its member dealers as one business. They compete in the same auction, so the fix is agreeing which terms each side owns.

Do I need a certified vendor to get co-op?

For Kia, Subaru and Stellantis, certification is what triggers automatic claims or reimbursement, and trade press reports Stellantis now reimburses digital marketing through DAP only via certified providers. Other brands’ rules sit behind dealer logins. Check your program guide before you sign with any vendor.

Is Tier 3 advertising mostly digital?

Yes. BIA forecasts 66.6% of new-car dealers’ 2026 local ad spend going to digital, and NADA says digital made up 74% of new-car dealer ad spend in 2025. The two figures differ because NADA counts listing sites and SEO, while BIA counts only local media.

Where to go from here

Open Auction insights on your brand search campaign for the last 90 days. If your dealer association’s domain shows a high overlap rate on your city terms, you are paying to compete with your own co-op money. That conversation with the association is worth more than any bid change.

Clickem runs Google Ads and Meta ads for car dealerships, auto repair shops, body shops and auto lenders. If you want an outside read on how your Tier 2 and Tier 3 campaigns overlap, see how we work as a dealer marketing agency or get in touch and we will tell you what the auction data shows.

Other articles